|
"A Strange Manuscript Found
in a Copper Cylinder" by
James De Mille
(1888)
Source: Wikimedia Commons |
Adam More tells of his discovery of a utopia (or in his
eyes, a dystopia) via a manuscript he seals in a copper cylinder. His journey
begins when More gets separated from his merchant’s ship with his friend,
Agnew. Using their rowboat, the two men drift until they find a desolate island
with devilish people as inhabitants. Upon first glance, More cannot stomach the
Natives and only goes ashore at Agnew's insistence. The Natives are described
by More as being less civilized and uglier than Aborigines, which he believes
to be the most uncivilized human beings. More's prejudicial fears are
well-founded, as Agnew is killed by the Natives.
However, More escapes the island and uses the boat to take
an adventure through a cave that is reminiscent of Verne's Journey to the
Center of the Earth. Eventually, More finds another strange land of
foreigners, but he is convinced that these people aren't dangerous from the landmarks
he sees as civilized, like roads, buildings and ships. When he meets these
strangers, his biased perspective of aliens is fully actualized: the first
Natives have black skin and are unkempt (thus, their appearance drove More's
distrust), but the second set of Natives have white skin and are what More describes
as 'regular'. More's encounter with the first set of Natives he meets
illustrates Ursula K. LeGuin's point in her article "American SF and the Other" when she speaks of aliens in sf becoming the Other, be it Galactic aliens, “sexual
aliens, class aliens, or cultural aliens.” (LeGuin). Because More does not
identify with the first Natives, he thinks them murderous Others from the
onset. Upon meeting the second Natives, he is assured of their innate kindness
as they more closely resembled what he associates with “regular” and civilized
human beings.
His view of the Natives, whom he later calls Kosekins,
changes when he learns of their value system that is basically an invert of
what he is used to back home in England. To start, Kosekins revere death and
hate the burden of living, thus they go on numerous hunts (in which women are
included) and basically throw themselves at the feet of the large animals they
pursue so as to die an honorable and public death. Secondly, Kosekins detest
wealth and aspire to poverty, viewing possessions as burdens. The poorest man
in the nation of Kosek has the most influence and respect, while the richest
man has the least respect (capitalism is seen as evil). In accordance with
their scorn of wealth, Kosekins are very self-sacrificing; they are always to
bestow gifts on one another (to get rid of their possessions/wealth), and when
one nation surrenders to another, it is considered a great honor and the
greatest possible instance of self-sacrifice. That is not to say that Kosekins
do not know of violence or war, but their reasons for war or violence differ
from the traditional reasons, as Kosekins fight when they receive too many
gifts from one person. When one is sick, all is done to nurse them back to
health, so that they may die in a more honorable way, yet when someone is sick,
every Kosekin trips over themselves to nurse the patient (as that is
self-sacrificing to care for someone else). Requited love among two human
beings is not a good thing in the Kosekin culture, because “love is
self-surrender, and utter self-abnegation. Love gives all away, and cannot
possibly receive anything in return. A requital of love would mean
selfishness.” Thus, the most self-sacrificing thing a Kosekin can do for the
person they love is to arrange their marriage to another. The most deterring
fact about Kosekins that More cannot get past is their sacrificial rituals.
When their comrades are wounded in battle, even from non-mortal wounds, they
kill their fallen brethren with a knife to the heart, and it is their duty to
do so. Not only do they kill their own, but they eat them as well, and it is
for that purpose that More and another foreigner of Kosek, Almah are in Kosek,
to be guests of honor at the next festival of cannibalism. While More might see
killing a fellow man and eating them as villainous acts, the Kosek see it as
bringing great honor to their fellow man. Almah tells More that he would not
deny a man that seeks life, the idea of it would go against all that he
believed in. Such is the Kosekins thoughts on denying a man death.
|
"Balls Pyramid" 13 Miles South of
Lord Howe Island
(2006)
Picture by Fanny Schertzer
Source: Wikimedia Commons |
More’s friend in Kosek, the Kohen, explains to him why
death is such a large part of their culture: “[To love death] is human nature.
We cannot help it; and it is what distinguishes us from animals.” The Kohen
goes further with his comparison of civilized Kosekins and animals, “Animals
fear death; animals love to accumulate such things as they prize; animals, when
they love, go in pairs, and remain with one another” (169). All of the things
that the Kosekins believe to be against human nature are things that only lowly
animals practice, like pairing, keeping possessions, and fearing death.
That is part of why the Kohen cannot understand More’s
point of view when More tells him that his culture fears death and loves life.
The Kohen tries his best to dissect More’s perspective by asking “If you really
fear death, what possible thing is there left to love or hope for?” To which
More replies, “Long life, and riches, and requited love”. After the Kohen’s
thoughts on those three unmoral life pursuits, More’s reasoning sounds selfish,
naïve, and unattainable.
Author James De Mille uses the inverted civilization of the
Kosekins to satire the foundations of the world’s “civilized” populations, much
in the fashion of Swift’s
Gulliver’s
Travels. At first, reading about the Kosek love of death and their desire
for poverty seems absurd, but their reasoning behind it makes sense against the
backdrop of humanity’s selfish pursuits for money, love, and a long life. Kosekins
live in both a utopian society and a dystopian one, because while their 180
degree way of life is admirable in a backwards way, their love of death (and
cannibalism) creates too wide of a gulf to reconcile their beliefs with More’s,
or with mine.
De
Mille, James. A Strange Manuscript Found
in a Copper Cylinder. New York: Harper and Brothers, 1888. Print.
LeGuin, Kroeber, Ursula. “America SF & The
Other”. Science Fiction Studies 2.3
(1975). Print.